First off, I don't think every episode is 5 stars, but the show as a whole is to me.
Jamey is the most knowledge ale and accurate on the show and is one of the only reasons I really listen. Gets to the point with no BS. Can be a bit harsh at times but it's all for purpose.
Adam is a great host and makes me really enjoy how he puts the show together and keeps the other two guys on track. He seems like a friend I don't even know, would love to grab a beer with the guy.
Dave is kind of just there, he gives some good stats and matchup advice but his takes are just all very old school and when compared to Jamey he just doesn't matchup. Still, he is a very loveable character from time to time with his humor.
Heath is the new(er) guy and I would honestly say he's a blend of the other three guys, probably the second guy I would go to for advice on my team after Jamey. Don't think he adds too much to the show in terms of character but I do like that he always finds middle ground on a lot of topics.
Overall, I love these guys and they've made my drives to work so enjoyable. I feel like I'm sitting there with them more than any other podcast. While I feel like their might be some better football information on the Harris Football podcast or better humor on the footballers pod, this is my favorite show end of story.