Note: As far as the film Nightmare Before Christmas goes, it deserves nothing less than 5 stars. Such an amazing feat of stop motion, music, voice talent, and both Halloween and Christmas celebration. However, as much as I could go on with why the film is fantastic, today we’re reviewing the Blu Ray 3D transfer here, not the actual film itself. However, I do leave 5 stars so iTunes will not be misled on what I think of the film itself.
In 2006, Disney post-converted an old movie to 3D for the first time: The Nightmare Before Christmas. When it got re released, people loved it so much that it subsequently got re released every October for a few more years afterwards. The film is of course available for home entertainment. Is it as good as the theatrical version? Or better yet, is it even good at all? That’s what we aim to analyze here Cinemablend style. So without further ado, let’s analyze if Nightmare Before Christmas is even more haunting in an extra dimension.
Does it fit 5/5
Disney made a solid choice making this their first past film to be converted to 3D, and it’s not hard to see why. From the bizarre world of Halloweentown to the light show in the Boogie Mans chamber to everything else in between, you’d be hard pressed to find why this film wouldn’t be a great fit for 3D. Of course, it wasn’t planned for 3D during its original production, but with the setting this film has, it should let you know that Disney is making a solid effort.
Planning and effort 3/5
Once again, this was Disney’s first 3D post converted film. So while they did put in the effort necessary to make it dazzling and full of depth, there were also plenty of issues as well. I’ll get to them in a minute, but it keeps the score from being higher than it is. I’m sure they did the best they could with their current experience in 2006. But I felt that if they’d actually watch the finished product for themselves, they could make a few adjustments that would’ve made the film better than it is. The film does automatically lose a point for not being made with 3D in mind to begin with. But if it weren’t for the issues we’ll mention below, it could’ve easily made a solid four.
Before the Window 3/5
Often times, in order for a 3D movie to have stuff popping out of the screen, the film needs to be made with 3D in mind from the beginning. That obviously wasn’t the case for Nightmare Before Christmas. But even with that, the film still does manage to make stuff come out at you. From ghosts at beginning to monsters to Jacks dog Zero to the Boogie Mans dice to even Jack Skellingtons head, this movie feels pretty comfortable coming into our world from time to time. These instances aren’t terribly frequent or in any way consistent. But they still help make this category much more memorable than most other 3D conversions.
Beyond the Window 4/5
It shouldn’t be a good sign when the first opening shot of a 3D film is virtually in perfect 2D. However, the good news is it only gets better from there. Much better in fact. As I said earlier, the setting creates opportunity for great dazzling depth. And the conversion team make great advantage of it. Halloweentown is no longer flat, but a lifelike wonderland. The moon in the graveyard looks far away like an actual moon. And every other scene that could use the depth goes above and beyond to make the depth an incredible part to the films experience. So why four out of five? Well, as I said earlier, be it the conversion teams accidental oversight or lack of experience, there are some quite distracting issues in this field. Aside from the flat opening shot, the depth that is provided sometimes doesn’t put objects in their own proper 3D space. Sometimes, objects that are supposed to be behind other objects are before them and vice versus. Other times, it appears that objects in the background are all, well, part of a flat background. Layering, as it is often called, is present in the 3D presentation. Although each of these individual problems don’t have too many instances on their own, the columniation of all them prevents the overall experience from being something you could “get lost in” like other presentations I’ve seen. Still though, the lack of depth isn’t the problem. In fact, it be extremely grand at times. But it’s because of these oversights that I’m giving it a 4/5.
Brightness 5/5
Surprisingly, with the dark and macabre setting of Halloweentown and the climax on the dark night of Christmas Eve, Nightmare Before Christmas remains every bit as bright and vibrant in 3D as it does in 2D.
Glasses off test 4/5
Rule of thumb: the blur you get on a 3D image with the glasses off, the more 3D you’re getting. That was very much the case throughout this film. With a few notable exceptions, this movie is very much unwatchable without the the 3D glasses.
Audience Health 5/5
Of the notable errors this movie has when making its way into 3D, I’m happy to say that unhealthy side effects aren’t one of them. Unless of course, your children feel butterflies in their stomach when the Boogie Man comes around all his 3D glory.
Conclusion 29/35
If it wasn’t for some of the uneven depth, oversights, and distracting layers, The Nightmare Before Christmas would be a great 3D movie. And I get it, going back and converting a film with such a bizarre setting like Nightmare can be pretty tricky at times. However, unless the conversion team plans on going back to this one to fix its issues, it only remains on the higher end of the good category of 3D movies. That being said, it’s still a recommended 3D presentation in spite of its flaws. And I can totally see why people liked it during its theatrical run. It provides tons of depth to enjoy, it brings the monsters closer to you, and to a degree, it just makes more sense to watch it in 3D. Overall, I suggest you getting it for a cheap price if you haven’t already. It’s not the best 3D conversion, but it’s still an extravagant and very memorable one.