Here is my track-by-track review:
1. Wake (1:41) - This is an instrumental, so I won't count it in the actual ratings. A good instrumental, though.
2. Given Up (3:09) - This song is fantastic. I'm sure many "Hybrid Theory" and "Meteora" fans listened to the first song on the album and went, "What do they mean, a big change from the previous albums? This is awesome!" The 17 second long scream by Chester is amazing; easily his best work. 10/10
3. Leave Out All The Rest (3:29) - This is the first real ballad LP ever released, and you can say most people were stunned. Some hated it, some loved it, some were indifferent. Me, I'm indifferent. I like it, but it's a bit repetitive and after the fast glee of "Given Up" this one doesn't seem as good in comparison. I used to really really like it when I heard it, so maybe I'm sick of it now. But, I will listen to it from time to time. 7/10
4. Bleed It Out (2:44) - For the people who say "At least 'Given Up,' No More Sorrow' and 'Bleed it Out' are like their previous two albums," you're wrong. "Given Up" and "No More Sorrow" may be, but "Bleed It Out" definitely isn't. It has one continuous guitar riff, whereas in "Meteora" we would have heard a bone-crushing power chord. Maybe people think it's like the previous two albums because of the screaming. OK, sorry for the ranting. It's a pretty good song; Mike's rapping is great. 8/10
5. Shadow Of The Day (4:49) - This song is... Different. Yes, Chester's vocals are extremely beautiful, but the whole song is literally one sound on loop until 3 minutes in. Then it gets slightly better, but not much. And the last 40 seconds is just some weird organ playing at 1% volume in the background... Can you say pointless? But, as I said again, Chester's vocals are a major redeeming quality... It just seems as though LP went a little overboard with the ballads on this one. 6/10
6. What I've Done (3:26) - This lead single could've been better, but definitely wasn't bad. It really is a mix of everything LP had done so far. The chorus reminds me of "Meteora," the bridge of "Hybrid Theory," and the whole song sounds like it had bits and pieces of "Leave Out All The Rest" mixed into it. So, I applaud them for that. 8/10
7. Hands Held High (3:53) - This song is just amazing. Period. I cannot believe LP is capable of something like this and doesn't do it more often. If you think this is just another stupid ballad, listen to the lyrics. They will change your life. 10/10
8. No More Sorrow (3:41) - Wow, two great songs in a row! "No More Sorrow" has over a minute of complete rocking instrumentals. Then it goes into the verse, then the chorus, which is great, as is the bridge. If you're feeling to rock out or feel mad, just listen to this song! 10/10
9. Valentine's Day (3:16) - Ah, we were going so great! This song is OK... At best. It can be boring and repetitive for sure, but the lyrics do mean more than you think they do, and the song improves when Chester goes into his yelling of "On Valentine's Day!" But still, it's definitely nothing special, but not unlistenable. 6/10
10. In Between (3:16) - This is the first song Mike sang on his own, and man, is it hella boring! Mike is a great singer, but he doesn't show his range in this song. Plus it's maybe two or three very quiet instruments. At least the lyrics and the melody in the chorus is decent. 4/10
11. In Pieces (3:38) - I love this song! Every thirty seconds or so, a new instrument is added! The song slowly builds until it's a full-out awesome song. Plus, Chester's lyrics and melodies are great. 10/10
12. The Little Things Give You Away (6:23) - This is a very good soft song, obviously rightly dissing George W. Bush and giving sympathy for the people caught in the Katrina storm. My only complaint-- WAY too long. 9/10
Average Rating: 8/10--four stars
Overall, "Minutes To Midnight" was definitely a change, but a successful one for the most part! A must-buy. If you only want to get a few songs, here's the songs ranked in order of which you should buy the most to least:
1. Given Up
2. Hands Held High
3. No More Sorrow
4. In Pieces
^^^The 10/10's--must buys
5. The Little Things Give You Away
^^^The 9/10--A very good choice
6. Bleed It Out
7. What I've Done
^^^The 8/10's--worth the money
8. Leave Out All The Rest
^^^The 7/10-- I guess I wouldn't un-recommend it.
9. Shadow Of The Day
10. Valentine's Day
^^^The 6/10's-- I wouldn't recommend it, although you may find something in them.
11. In Between
^^^The 4/10-- You shouldn't get this song.